When Jesus Said ‘Cut It Off’—and What He Really Meant: The Most Misunderstood Line Jesus Ever Spoke

"If your right eye causes you to sin, tear it out and throw it away… if your right hand causes you to sin, cut it off and throw it away." (Mt 5:29–30)

For years I thought Jesus was expressing a hyperbole—a shocking metaphor to tell us to take sin seriously. Even to practice radical amputation: cut off whatever in your life is causing you to stumble.

While it’s true we should take sin seriously, it's missing the deeper message.

As a clinical psychologist, I've seen how this passage often affects people. They judge themselves harshly, drowning in shame, wondering if they're really taking sin seriously enough. The internal voice whispers, "If you truly loved God, wouldn't you go this far?"

But watch what happens if we follow this logic: A lustful man sins with his hands, so he cuts them off. Still sins with his eyes—gouges them out. Sins with his tongue—cuts that out too. On and on until he's just a limbless, senseless torso on a bed, and yet he can still lust, hate, envy, and rage within.

Jesus is creating this uncomfortable dilemma on purpose. He's using the same logic the Law was designed to produce—bringing condemnation to help us recognize our desperate need for grace.

The realization He's driving us toward? There's only one body part that actually causes us to sin, and it's the one we can't cut out ourselves—our heart.

The Real Problem: The Heart

Notice what comes just before: "Everyone who looks at a woman with lust has already committed adultery with her in his heart" (Matt 5:28).

Jesus is dismantling the idea that righteousness is primarily about external compliance. Sin doesn't begin in our behavior—it begins in our heart. By the time sin reaches your hands, it has already conquered your heart.

As He taught elsewhere, "Out of the heart come evil thoughts, murder, adultery, sexual immorality, theft, false witness, slander" (Matthew 15:19). The heart is the control center of human personality. But as the philosopher Pascal once said, “The heart has reasons which reason knows nothing of,” and when our hearts are corrupted, everything flowing from it becomes corrupted.

This is why behavior modification always fails. You can cut off the branches, but if the root remains poisoned, new growth emerges just as toxic.

A Heart Transplant Only God Can Do

This is where the Gospel explodes in its brilliance. Jesus isn't advocating sin management—He's pointing to heart replacement.

Centuries earlier, Ezekiel prophesied:

"I will remove from you your heart of stone and give you a heart of flesh. I will put my Spirit within you, and cause you to walk in my statutes and be careful to obey my rules" (Ezekiel 36:26–27).

But here's where it gets even more beautiful—this heart transformation is what Paul calls the "circumcision of the heart" (Romans 2:29). If physical circumcision was cutting away flesh to mark God's people, then spiritual circumcision cuts away the hardened heart to reveal the tender one underneath.

This happens through faith—through encountering Jesus in the Gospel, through the conviction of the Holy Spirit, through baptism that unites us to Christ's death and resurrection. "In him also you were circumcised with a circumcision made without hands, by putting off the body of the flesh, by the circumcision of Christ, having been buried with him in baptism" (Colossians 2:11-12).

Christianity isn't behavior modification—it's heart transformation. We don't get a spiritual tune-up; we get a whole new engine. As Paul writes, "I have been crucified with Christ, and it is no longer I who live, but Christ lives in me" (Galatians 2:20).

It's faith in His love that overcomes us, not our determination to overcome sin.

From Stone to Flesh

This truth inspired one of my songs, Overshadow Me (Ruach).

The chorus cries out: "Take from me this heart of stone, let it beat for You alone."

That's not a plea for willpower—it's a prayer of surrender. A heart of stone is hard, unresponsive, dead. But a heart of flesh is soft, sensitive, alive. It responds to God's touch and naturally desires what He desires.

This transformation isn't gradual improvement—it's resurrection. And the Spirit doesn't do this begrudgingly. He delights to replace our hardened heart with one alive in His love.

The Enemy's Strategy: Attacking the Heart

Here's where understanding spiritual warfare becomes crucial. In my book Big God, Little Devil, I explore how the enemy's tactics are far more subtle than we realize. The word "discouragement" literally means "against the heart"—from the French coeur (heart).

Before the enemy can gain real influence over us, he must first attack our heart, our hope, our trust in God's protection. Before we truly become afraid, we must first despair.

But when Jesus gives us His heart, we get a heart that is courageous and free from discouragement because it is secure in God. This new heart can't be dis-couraged because it has been en-couraged with the very courage of Christ.

How to Receive It

Here's the beautiful truth: we know He first seeks us. Before we ever thought to look for Him, He was already pursuing us. So we don't have to earn this heart transplant or work our way into it—we just have to show up hungry, knowing there's a table prepared for us in His presence.

We receive this new heart not by striving, but by faith. By the simple posture of opening our hands and saying, "Lord, I can't change myself, but You can."

It's not about gouging out your eye—it's about letting Him give you new vision. It's not about chopping off your hand—it's about letting Him hold you with His. It's not about silencing your tongue—it's about Him putting His word on your lips.

The Christian life is not mutilation. It's transfiguration.

The Invitation

So here's the question: will you stop trying to fix yourself and let Him do the surgery?

We can't change our own hearts. We need a heart transplant, and only Jesus offers it. When He does, our poverty turns into joy. Our emptiness becomes His dwelling. Our stony silence breaks into praise.

This is the Gospel hidden in Jesus' most shocking command—not endless self-improvement, but supernatural transformation. Not better behavior, but a better heart. Jesus isn't condemning us to spiritual self-mutilation; He's inviting us to the most beautiful surgery imaginable—one that leaves us more whole than we ever dreamed possible.

May this be our prayer: "Take from me this heart of stone. Let it beat for You alone."

If you want to explore more about how God's greatness eclipses the enemy's tactics and how to live free from fear-based Christianity, I invite you to check out my book Big God, Little Devil. The war is won, the enemy is disarmed—so why are so many Christians still living in fear? It's time to live like it.

If this resonated with you, please share it with someone who needs to hear it. Subscribe for more insights on faith, psychology, and spiritual freedom—and consider supporting this work with a paid subscription to help me continue bringing you content that bridges theology and psychology.

About Dr. Sean Tobin

Dr. Sean Tobin is a clinical psychologist, worship leader, and writer passionate about integrating faith and psychology. A convert from atheism, Sean has a background in healing and deliverance ministry. He has a burden for Christian unity, a heart for the spiritual orphan, and a passion to live the culture of Pentecost.

Follow: @drseantobin | @biggodlittledevil